The Netherlands has teamed up with four other European countries to build a “return hub” in Rwanda, where rejected asylum seekers who can’t be sent home could be relocated from next year.
The plan targets people who have gone through the entire Dutch asylum process and have no right to stay, but who refuse to leave or aren’t welcome in their own country. Together with Germany, Austria, Denmark and Greece, the cabinet unveiled the idea at a migration conference in Vienna on Monday, November 16.
If it goes ahead, it would be the first time EU countries send rejected asylum seekers to a country they’re not from, NOS reports.
Who would end up in Rwanda?
For now, only single men, mainly from countries in the region around Rwanda, according to the Dutch government.
Families won’t be sent in the first phase, and unaccompanied minors are excluded entirely. Anyone facing a real risk of persecution is also off the list. RTL Nieuws gives LGBTQ+ people as an example, since their situation in Rwanda can be difficult.
In addition, numbers will be small at first, with Rwanda making 100 places available. Together, the five countries expect to send a few dozen people.
In an attempt to put a positive spin on things, the government describes the hub as an “open facility” rather than a detention centre. People sent there would get the right to live in Rwanda, plus access to education, work, healthcare and the legal system.
“Of course, the migrant can always still choose to return to their country of origin,” the government adds in its announcement.
Why is the Netherlands doing this?
“Return is an essential part of our asylum system and crucial for public support for reception,” Foreign Affairs Minister Tom Berendsen of the CDA (the Christian Democrats) said in Vienna, according to NOS. Put simply, the cabinet believes people will only accept housing asylum seekers if those who lose their case actually leave.
The Dutch government also sees the hub as a fallback for when sending someone back to their own country just isn’t possible.
The five countries think the timing is finally right, too. Earlier attempts to send people to a third country got stuck in court, but new EU rules on returns now allow it, as long as agreements are made with that country first, RTL Nieuws reports.
Critics aren’t convinced
Vluchtelingenwerk (the Dutch Council for Refugees) points to the country’s own immigration service.
“The IND itself has concluded that Rwanda cannot be classified as a safe third country,” director Sjoerd Warmerdam has previously told RTL Nieuws. A safe third country is one considered safe to send asylum seekers to, even though they aren’t from there.
Anna Strolenberg, an MEP for the progressive party Volt, recently visited Rwanda to look into the plan. “There’s no press freedom, no political freedom and no opposition in Rwanda,” she told ANP earlier, as reported by Nieuws.nl.
Amnesty International and Save the Children have also raised concerns about how migrants will be treated, while France and Spain worry about possible human rights violations. On the other side, Ulysse Ellian, an MP for the right-wing liberal VVD, welcomed the plan and urged a quick rollout.
British readers may get déjà vu: the UK scrapped its own Rwanda scheme in 2024 without a single deportation flight, after spending £700 million on it, as Al Jazeera reported at the time.
Don’t expect planes to Kigali just yet
The five countries plan to sign a deal with Rwanda early next year, and the cabinet is aiming for the first transfers in 2027. Even the cabinet expects the plan to end up in court first, though, and it would only become standard policy if Europe’s highest courts approve it.
In the Netherlands, people can stay in the country while their case is being decided, which could easily take two years, RTL Nieuws reports. Denmark is a little more optimistic, hoping for its first flights by the end of 2027.
The costs will be shared between the five countries, but nobody has named a figure yet. Rwanda may not be the last stop either: the group is also talking to Kenya, Ghana, Uzbekistan and Uganda, which a previous Dutch cabinet had already eyed for a similar hub.
Do you agree with the return hub policy or find it unethical? Let us know in the comments below!




