Should the Netherlands open its doors to the Yazidi refugees?

The Yazidis, Islamic State’s genocide and sexual slavery victims, haven’t necessarily found a safe haven in the Netherlands.

In August 2014, the world’s eyes turned to a mountain plateau in northern Iraq known as Sinjar. The headlines captured the Islamic State’s (IS) brutal attack on the Yazidis, one of Iraq’s oldest religious minorities.

Thousands of men and boys were executed and dumped in mass graves. Thousands of women and girls, some as young as nine, were kidnapped and sold into sexual slavery. Meanwhile, many more boys were taken from their families and forced into IS training camps.

The United Nations would later determine that the attack on Sinjar, and the ongoing enslavement, constitutes genocide.

Who are the Yazidis?

The Yazidis are mainly of Kurdish ethnicity, and their religion is a mix of Christianity, Islam, and Zoroastrism, an anciant Persian religion. A long-persecuted minority, the Yazidis worship a fallen angel, Melek Tawwus, or Peacock Angel. Contrary to Satan’s fall from grace in the Judeo-Christian tradition, Melek Tawwus was forgiven and returned to heaven.

Due to the importance of the Peacock Angel in the Yazidi’s faith, they received an unjust reputation as devil worshipers. In the times of religious extremism led by IS, professing such faith became a death warrant.

The aftermath

Despite the end of IS’ so-called caliphate in Iraq, the Yazidi plight continues. They are scattered, but the collective trauma that bounds them together is unfathomable. In total, almost 10,000 people were murdered, and about 6,000 women and children were abducted and sold. Around 3,000 of those are still missing.

Part of the women who were rescued shared shocking accounts of being sold and resold into sexual slavery, constant beatings and rapes, and other extreme forms of abuse suffered at the hands of IS fighters and their wives, many of whom had fled Europe to join the group.

Nobel Peace Prize

One of these women is Nadia Murad. She won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2018, which she shared with Denis Mukwege, a gynaecologist from the Democratic Republic of Congo who also fights against sexual violence in war. Nadia was captured alongside her sisters and lost six brothers and her mother when IS attacked Sinjar.

She decided to tell her story, constantly reliving the horrors of what she was put through, in order to seek justice and bring awareness to the fate shared by so many Yazidi women. She called her autobiography The Last Girl, because her fight is to be the last girl in the world with such a story.

Lingering in and around camps

The majority of the internally displaced Yazidis live in the Kurdish region of Iraq, in or outside refugee camps. The standards of accommodation vary from precarious tents without cement bases and abandoned buildings, to more comfortable rented apartments. Economic destitution and poor infrastructure are the norm.

Yazidi refugees at this camp in northern-Syria walked up to 60km in searing temperatures through the Sinjar mountains, while many suffered severe dehydration. Image: Rachel Unkovic/International Rescue Committee/Flickr

The refugees had walked up to 60km in searing temperatures through the Sinjar mountains and many had suffered severe dehydration.

There are currently around 400,000 Yazidis living in Iraqi Kurdistan. This means that humanitarian help and local services are stretched over the limit, leaving people in dire circumstances with no means to cope with such traumatic experiences. Doctors without borders has blown the whistle on a severe mental health crisis among the Yazidi, which includes high numbers of suicides and suicide attempts.

Brainwashed youth

The Yazidi boys who were abducted and forced to join IS’ as child soldiers underwent an extreme brainwashing program. IS laced the boys’ food with amphetamines as a way to reduce fear, and trained a part of them as suicide bombers. Many saw their father being murdered before being taken. Numerous were sent to the bloodiest frontlines.

Many were bought back by their families from IS for large sums of money, but as they return a deep identity crisis unfolds. A vast number of them are still indoctrinated and renounce their families and their faith, oftentimes violently. Suicide is rampant in what has been described as “a mental-health crisis unlike any in the world”.  Some very young Yazidi girls who were abducted and sold into IS’s families to be raised as Muslims are now back with what remains of their families and face a similar crisis.

The forgotten people

Dutch writer and freelance journalist, Brenda Stoter Boscolo, has written a book in which she details the Yazidi genocide through personal stories. The book’s title, The Forgotten People, is grim and seems accurate. Brenda has been to the region many times and has conducted extensive interviews with the Yazidi.

In an interview with DutchReview she expressed the Yazidi’s disbelief in the slow response of the international community. “They are very proud of Nadia’s Nobel, but they feel it is clearly not enough.”

According to Boscolo, the debate around the repatriation of European IS women living in camps in the Middle East is a sore point in the Yazidi community. “We have also been living in precarious camps for years, why don’t they pick us up?” she often hears. Through her writing and reporting, Boscolo is on an active campaign to remind the Dutch public to include the Yazidi plight when discussing what should be done with Dutch IS fighters and the women who chose to join them. “It is an often-neglected topic,” Boscolo points out.

The quest for justice

When asked what is the best way forward, Boscolo becomes silent for a few seconds on the phone. “There is no easy, clear solution,” she says. “The world needs to acknowledge the genocide and punish the perpetrators. That’s the only way to bring peace to the Yazidis. In order to move on from the trauma, there must be justice.”

This is a sentiment shared by other people fighting for Yazidi rights in the Netherlands. Pari Ibrahim was studying law in the Netherlands when news of the genocide broke; a Yazidi herself with 40 members of her family missing, she soon founded the Free Yazidi foundation. Nowadays she travels the world raising awareness and seeking justice for the Yazidi. Her foundation has also established women and children centers in refugee camps, offering much-needed services for the displaced population.


The number of accepted asylum requests from the Yazidi community in Europe has fallen sharply since the height of the crisis. The Dublin accord, which requires asylum seekers to stay in the first country where they are fingerprinted, has also meant that people who know each other and could act as a support network, may end up faraway once in Europe.

Asylum in the Netherlands

In the first semester of 2019, the Dutch immigration and naturalization service, the IND, announced it would send Yazidi asylum seekers back to camps Iraq. The argument the IND offered was that there was enough food and shelter in the camps. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) immediately condemned the decision. The UN body released a statement stating that it was unreasonable to assume that resettling in Iraq was a viable alternative when there are clear issues regarding their safety, protection of basic rights and economic destitution.

After wide condemnation, including from many political parties, the Dutch State Secretary for Security and Justice, Ankie Broekers-Knol, said that the government was backtracking its decision. The Secretary recognized the extremely challenging situation the Yazidis face in Iraq, and said that from now on they would be seen in the Netherlands as a vulnerable minority group. This new classification, consistent with the recognition of the Yazidi genocide, means that residency permits would be a little easier to get. Even though this policy reversal is good news, it is far from fast-tracking resettlement programs in place in other countries, such as Germany and Canada.

What is your opinion? Should the Dutch government take similar steps and open its borders to the resettlement of larger numbers of Yazidi survivors? Let us know your opinion in the comments below. 

Feature Image: Rachel Unkovic/International Rescue Committee/Flickr

Maria Rita Reis
Maria Rita is an ex-International Relations teacher on a lifelong affair with the news. She enjoys reading about light topics such as minorities, terrorism, and war. An immigrant, a polyglot and a very curious human, she's always rooting for the underdog. Keeping up with international politics and understanding the power of language are two of her biggest passions. Not surprisingly, a lot of her time is spent drinking obscene amounts of coffee and laughing at silly linguistics memes.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related posts

Latest posts

Dutch HORECA rarely reprimanded for ignoring coronavirus measures

HORECA establishments aren't complying with the coronavirus measures, and municipalities are not giving them so much as a warning for this. On September 25,...

You’re under arrest: thousands of Dutchies targeted by phishing calls

Since August, thousands of Dutchies have received suspicious phone calls in which cyber-criminals try to get their personal information, such as citizen service (BSN)...

Nee, echt?! One of the wettest natural areas in the Netherlands is drying up

Nature lovers may already be familiar with the Dutch nature reserve called the Veluwe. The 91,200-hectare area is a popular recreational area that offers...

The latest Dutch news.
In your inbox.