Ethical or not? The Mauritshuis hangs artwork made by AI in place of loaned Vermeer

From February 6 to June 4, an AI version of Vermeer’s Girl with a Pearl Earring is being displayed at the Mauritshuis in The Hague.

While the real Vermeer painting is away at the once-in-a-lifetime exhibition at the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam, Julian Van Dieken’s AI version of the painting has taken its place, reports de Volkskrant.

A Girl with Glowing Earrings

The Mauritishuis didn’t want the original display area to get chilly. 🥶

Therefore, they made a call to artists from near and far to create a new piece inspired by the famous Vermeer painting. 

Before long, curators had to sift through 3,482 art pieces made from photographs, sculptures, and even work composed of vegetables before they landed upon an AI model of the piece to hang in a row with four others.

READ MORE | Girl with a Pearl Earring vandalised by climate protesters

This decision has been scrutinised under the watchful eyes of many art critics, who aren’t happy that the hard labour of artists is being mocked by a bot.

How was it made?

Julian Van Dieken created AI-generated images of the girl using the artificial intelligence programme Midjourney. He went on to fine-tune her beauty digitally with Photoshop. 

READ MORE | Dutch students are using artificial intelligence to complete their homework

Midjourney works with a simple text input. This means Van Dieken might’ve typed in: Create a portrait of Vermeer’s Girl with a Pearl Earring — with a bit of glow and shine. ✨

Then, the system creates a computer-generated image faster than a Dutchie can say leuk!

Artificial intelligence or artificial ignorance? 

Objections from the art world are also moving quickly as artists campaign against AI entering their space.

One artist, Eva Toorenent, advocates against the ‘unethical technology’ used to create these artworks, with the organisation EGAIR.

“While Midjourney makes a lot of money with its software, the artists and creators whose work is involuntarily included in this dataset see nothing in return,” Toorenent tells de Volkskrant.

READ MORE | Patients in this Dutch hospital will now be treated by…Artificial Intelligence?

“Without the work of human artists, this program could not generate works at all. The higher the quality of art in the dataset, the higher the quality of the AI ​​art.”

Whilst artificial intelligence may be useful for some professions, Toorenent believes that within the art profession, AI should be a no-go.

What do you think of the AI Vermeer painting? Tell us in the comments below!

Feature image:Depositphotos

Accuracy, clarity, and a touch of humour — that’s DutchReview. Read our editorial mission.

Eva Gabriella
Eva Gabriella
After calling Malaysia her home for 19 years, Eva moved to Amsterdam to study literary and cultural analysis. Well, that was the academic theory — in reality it was more like “cultural shock.” Eva’s mastery of life in the Netherlands involved initiation into the richness of nocturnal hangouts, canals, cuisine, and upright and forthright cyclists (who she now rings her bell back at.) When she is not speeding her way through books, she is winding and weaving down endless straatjes, often finding herself, not so quite by chance, in a gezellig music bar!

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related posts

Latest posts

The Netherlands is about to see a solar eclipse AND a meteor shower (all in one night)

If you're an astronomy nerd, it's time to dust off your telescope and talk your friends into joining you in a field at 3...

Pride attendee beaten and verbally abused by minor, victim’s sexual orientation was suspected motive

A minor was arrested yesterday after an attendee of Zandvoort's Pride on the Beach festival was assaulted. The assault took place on the Grote Krocht...

The geography of the Netherlands explained (video inside!)

The Netherlands has islands, over 70 animal species, and, to say the least, it's very flat. Travelling across this tiny country from the east...

It's happening

Upcoming events